⭐️FREE Marie Sharp's or Dirty Dick's Hot Sauce 5 oz with Select Orders $50+
⭐️FREE Marie Sharp's or Dirty Dick's Hot Sauce 5 oz with Select Orders $50+
-34% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's Smokin' Marie Habanero Pepper Sauce 5 oz. Case of 6 $39.99 $60.00
Fruitwood smoked fresh red Belizean habanero pepper, hand chopped carrots, natural vinegar, hand chopped white onions, natural sea salt, freshly squeezed key lime juice, and fresh garlic - Mindfully made in Belize, Central America. This amazing sauce starts with the classic recipe that made Marie world famous, but the peppers are smoked using four different types of fruit wood; Craboo wood, Grapefruit Wood, Guava wood and Orange wood.  The result is an exquisite and deeply intense, exotic smoke aroma that is unique and will permeate any dish with rich flavor.  If you enjoy chipotle flavors, this sauce is for you. Not for people who dislike smoke flavor, a small amount of this sauce will infuse smoked flavor in a large batch of beans, collards, dips, mashed potatoes or in place of ham or bacon in any dish. What's the difference between "Smoked" & "Smokin Marie"? Smokin Marie has less carrot and more smoked peppers.
-34% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's Green Cactus Habanero Pepper Sauce 5oz. Case of 6 $39.99 $60.00
Hand chopped fresh Belizean Nopal, green habanero pepper, natural vinegar, freshly squeezed key lime juice, sea salt, hand chopped white onions and fresh garlic - Mindfully made by Marie Sharp in Belize, Central America. Nopal, or Opuntia cacti, are native to arid areas of Central, South and North America.  There are more than one hundred and fourteen species endemic to Mexico and the Yucatan, where the plant is a common ingredient in numerous dishes.   Marie uses Nopal in this extraordinary way, as a base for a delicious, vegetable forward sauce that is unlike any other "green" sauce you or your loved ones have tried.  Get Marie's Green Habanero pepper sauce NOW and experience the clean, natural flavor of nopal, for yourself!
-34% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's Original Hot Pepper Sauce 5 oz. Case of 6 $39.99 $60.00
World's Best Hot Sauce Introducing HOT: Marie Sharp's Original Recipe Crafted with care in Belize, Central America, our HOT sauce features fresh hand-chopped carrots, chopped white onions, natural vinegar, select red Belizean habanero peppers, freshly squeezed key lime juice, hand-harvested snowy white sea salt, and fresh garlic. This is the original 1981 recipe that sparked a culinary revolution. The fruity essence of habanero peppers is delicately balanced by the sweetness of fresh carrots, offering a subtle heat that's a few notches above the familiar heat tolerances of North America. Elegant and structured, with a clean finish, our sauces are non-fermented, setting them apart from typical vinegar-based hot sauces. Marie Sharp's sauces, dubbed "Pepper Sauces," highlight the natural flavors of fruits and vegetables, devoid of the sharpness and acidity often found in vinegar-based counterparts. Marie Sharp's most popular recipe, the white label, is the #1 selling Habanero Pepper sauce on the planet, available in more than 30 countries.
-16% sale
Cheese Brothers, Inc. Sharp & Flavorful Cheese Box (8 Cheeses) $84.95 $99.95
Description Shipping Ingredients Do you like cheese with a bite? This collection is for you. We packed eight blocks of our most flavorful cheeses together in this assortment. Try classics like our eight-year-aged Cheddar or get acquainted with new varieties like the limited edition Door County Duet. This one is perfect for charcuterie plates and wine and cheese pairings. Contents: Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.  Two 6 oz. blocks of our classic Sharp Cheddar Two 6 oz. blocks of Fratello, an Italian-style cheese One 5 oz. block of our limited-edition Door County Duet* One 5 ox. block of our 15-year Aged Cheddar Two 5 oz. blocks of our extra sharp and rich 8-year-aged Cheddar    *Door Country Duet is not vegetarian and is made with animal rennet in a separate facility with Trappiste (also vegetable rennet) to avoid cross-contamination. Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. Ingredients Sharp Cheddar: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Door County Duet: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, animal-derived enzymes. 8-year Aged Cheddar: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, may contain annatto (color). 15-year Aged Cheddar: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, may contain annatto (color). Fratello: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes.
Cheese Brothers, Inc. The Char-CURD-erie Box $69.95
Description Shipping Ingredients For a delicious cheese and meat spread without the prep, our Char-CURD-erie Box always delivers. Packed with freshly made to order Wisconsin cheese curds, classic summer sausage, and locally made Cherry Lavender jam, this delightful assortment is the perfect spread to impress at your next game day or holiday gathering. No slicing necessary. Just open and serve! Never tried a cheese curd? These tasty morsels are a Wisconsin staple, known for their fresh taste and springy texture that "squeaks" when you eat them. Ours are made fresh daily in an array of original flavors. Secure yours today for cold pack shipping direct to your door! Contents: Three 8 oz. bags of freshly made to order Wisconsin cheese curds (Tomato Basil, Bloody Mary, and Hot Pepper). Two 6 oz. bag of freshly made to order Wisconsin cheese curds (Classic, and Garlic Dill) Two 8 oz. Barron Sausage Co. summer sausages  One 8 oz. jar of Cherry Lavender Jam from Bushel and Peck of Beloit, Wisconsin. *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged. Ingredients Classic: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Garlic Dill: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, garlic seasoning (granulated garlic and dill weed). Bloody Mary: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto(Color), Tomatoes, Hot Bloody Mary Spice (Salt, Spices, Maltodextrin, Onion & Garlic Powder, Worcestershire Sauce [Vinegar, Molasses, CornSyrup, Salt, Garlic Powder, Caramel Color, Sugar, Spices, Tamarind, Natural Flavor], Dextrose, Extractives of Turmeric, Natural Flavors, Less Than 2% Silicon Dioxide(prevents caking)). Tomato Basil: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Tomato, and Basil. Ranch: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Ranch Seasoning (Maltodextrin, Buttermilk, Salt, Monosodium Glutamate, Dried Garlic, Dried Onion, Lactic Acid, Calcium Lactate, Spices, Citric Acid, Less Than 1% of: Calcium Stearate, Artificial Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Carboxymethyl cellulose, Guar Gum, Natural Flavors). Barron Sausage Co. Summer Sausage: Beef, salt, dextrose, spices, sugar, lactic acid starter culture, sodium ascorbate, sodium nitrite. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
Cheese Brothers, Inc. Deluxe Hot and Spicy Gift Collection $49.95
Description Shipping Ingredients If spicy is what they're after, spicy is what you'll give with this hot and toasty collection. We include four of our spiciest cheeses, from the relatively tame Honey Sriracha Gouda to our burning hot "El Diablo" Scorpion Pepper Gouda. To top it off we've included two of our favorite locally produced hot sauces, both as flavorful as they are spicy. So strap in and get ready to feel the burn! Contents: Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.  One 6 oz. block of "El Diablo" Scorpion Pepper Gouda One 6 oz. block of "Bantam" Honey Sriracha Gouda One 6 oz. block of "El Perrito" Mango Habanero Gouda One 6 oz. block of "3 Amigos" Jalapeno, Chipotle, and Habanero Gouda One 8 oz. jar of Holy Ghost hot sauce from Bushel & Peck of Beloit, WI One 8 oz. jar of Fatalii Attraction hot sauce from Bushel & Peck   *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page. Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged. Ingredients "El Diablo" Scorpion Pepper Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, scorpion chili peppers, annatto coloring. "Bantam" Honey Sriracha Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. Flavoring: Honey granules, salt, spices, dextrose, onion, sriracha sauce (aged cayenne red peppers, vinegar, garlic), sugar, brown sugar, garlic powder, maltodextrin, sodium diacetate, natural flavor. "El Perrito" Mango Habanero Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. Flavoring: Sugar, dried honey (refinery syrup, honey), maltodextrin, habanero peppers, spices, natural mango flavor. 3 Amigos: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, jalapeno, habanero, chipotle peppers, annatto coloring. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
Cheese Brothers, Inc. Brothers' Favorites Wisconsin Cheese Box $84.95
Description Shipping Ingredients Give the ultimate gift for the diehard foodie in your life. Four artisan cheeses (including our rich and decadent 8-Year-Aged Cheddar) make a perfect pairing for a classic mustard from Mustard and Co., blueberry jalapeño jam from Beloit's own Bushel and Peck, and Wisconsin-made organic crackers. For dessert, we include bite-sized caramels handmade in our home region of northern Wisconsin. These are our favorite items in our collection, and we think you'll love them too. *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Contents: Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.  Three 6 oz. blocks of Wisconsin-made cheese (3 Amigos Gouda, Fratello, Smoked Gouda)
 One 5 oz. block of Wisconsin-made 8-Year-Aged Cheddar
 One 8 oz. jar of Classic mustard from Mustard and Co. of Seattle, WA
(Due to supply chain shortages, the Mustard and Co. mustard will be replaced with Bier Hall Stone Mustard) One 8 oz. jar of Blueberry Jalapeño Jam from Bushel and Peck of Beloit, WI
 One 5 oz. package of bite-sized caramels by Sugarwood of Cumberland, WI
 One 5 oz. package of Classic White organic crackers from Potter's Crackers of Madison, Wisconsin
 (replacing Six-Seed crackers pictured)   *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page. Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged. Ingredients 3 Amigos Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, jalapeno, habanero, chipotle peppers, annatto coloring. Fratello: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Smoked Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. 8-Year-Aged Cheddar: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
Cheese Brothers, Inc. Deluxe Charcuterie Pack $124.95
Description Shipping Ingredients Packed with fine Wisconsin cheese, gourmet meats, and handmade artisan treats, this collection is ready to go for your next gathering or deluxe holiday gift. We start with the cheese. There are the nutty, delicately smoked Adelheid and sharp and zesty 8-Year-Aged Cheddar, the mild and creamy Fratello and Dill Havarti, the smooth and spicy 3 Amigos Gouda and finally, our famous Smoked Gouda, smoked in our natural wood-fired ovens here in Barron. We pair it with classic Wisconsin summer sausage from our very own Barron Sausage Co. Pair your meat and cheese with delicious Cherry Lavender jam from Wisconsin's own Bushel and Pecks, or a fine classic mustard from the artisans at Mustard and Co. Best enjoyed with family and friends! Contents: Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.    Eight 6 oz. blocks of Wisconsin cheese (Dill Havarti, Fratello, Smoked Adelheid, 3 Amigos Gouda, and Smoked Gouda). Two 5 oz. blocks of Wisconsin reserve cheese (8-Year-Aged Cheddar) Two 8 oz. Wisconsin summer sausages from our very own Barron Sausage Co.  One 8 oz. jar of Cherry Lavender Jam from Bushel and Peck of Beloit, Wisconsin. One 7 oz. jar of hand-made Bier Hall Stone Ground Mustard One 5 oz. package of Classic White organic crackers from Potter's Crackers of Madison, Wisconsin
      *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
-10% sale
The Pepper Pantry Pantry Pack Mixed Set of Four $47.25 $52.50
Try a pack of four of our newest product offerings!  FOUR pack includes: Heartbeat Pineapple Habanero Hot Sauce Heartbeat has yet again collaborated with an Ontario craft brewery, this time from their hometown of Thunder Bay. Made with the help of Sleeping Giant Brewery's award-winning Beaver Duck session IPA, this sauce has a boldly pronounced fruitiness and a bright but savory vibe from start to finish. This sauce has a very approachable balance of heat and flavor, a Heartbeat signature characteristic! Historic Lynchburg Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning is a sure fire way to get perfect Nashville chicken flavor every time.  Mike's Hot Honey Honey with a Kick | America's #1 Brand of Hot HoneyMike's Hot Honey is a sweet-heat combo of honey infused with chili peppers that adds the perfect kick to all of your favorite foods. Dawson's Shawarma Sauce This sauce is heavily influenced by Middle Eastern spice blends and the culture of      take-out Shawarma shops. Our Shawarma Sauce is mild, incredibly bright in taste, with smooth notes from garlic, extra virgin olive oil and honey. The spice blend is familiar, yet unique in a hot sauce and a must try!
-10% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's Tasting Flight | 13-Pack Set $45.00 $50.00
Marie Sharp's Tasting Flight | 13-Pack Set The Perfect Dozen plus One!   13 x 1.69 Ounce (50 ml) Bottle of the following flavors: Beware Belizean Heat Original Mild Original Hot Original Fiery Hot Garlic Grapefruit Green (Nopal) Mango Orange Smoked Smokin' Marie Sweet Begin rescuing boring food one flavor at a time!
-10% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's BBQ Lovers | 3-Pack Set* $37.80 $42.00
Marie Sharp's BBQ Lovers | 3-Pack Set Rule your patio with this sauciest set ever! 1 x 10 Ounce Bottle of the following flavors: BELIZEAN BBQ (GOLD LABEL) BELIZEAN BBQ (SMOKY LABEL) SWEET HABANERO + FREE MINI Sauce Use each sauce separately or combine them to unlock YOUR very own unique blend!
-10% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's Better Belize it | 4-Pack Set $36.00 $40.00
Must Have! - Better Belize it | 4-Pack Set This popular set includes 4 bottles: 1 x 5 Ounce Bottle of the following flavors ORIGINAL MILD ORIGINAL HOT BEWARE MANGO + FREE Mini 50 ml bottle An excellent combination of flavors for the chef in YOU!
-10% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's Chef's Choice | 4-Pack Set $36.00 $40.00
Top Seller Chef's Choice | 4-Pack Set   Our most popular set includes: 1 x 5 Ounce Bottle of the following flavors GREEN NOPAL HABANERO ORIGINAL HOT GARLIC PEPPER SWEET HABANERO + FREE MINI The perfect combination of flavors for the chef in YOU!
-10% sale
Marie Sharp's Marie Sharp's Dad's Hot Off the Grill | 4-Pack Set $36.00 $40.00
Must Have! - Dad's Hot off the Grill | 4-Pack Set This popular set includes 4 bottles: 1 x 5 Ounce Bottle of the following flavors SMOKIN' MARIE SWEET HABANERO  BEWARE MANGO + FREE Mini 50 ml bottle An excellent combination of flavors for the chef in Dad or YOU!
Rufus Teague STEAK LOVER'S KIT $20.95
Rufus Teague knows that you don't mess with steak. So listen up if you think steak by itself is as good as it gets. This... gift kit... will... change... your... mind. Definitely not your typical grocery store steak sauce slop. Nope, these sauces are bold and bright and work on everything. And you also get a bottle of the most amazing spice your steak can handle. All in one kit!
Rufus Teague SAUCIN' & RUBBIN' KIT (4 pack) $26.95
Give someone the gift of Rufus. All dolled up in this cool little box. You get one of each: Honey Sweet BBQ Sauce, Touch O' Heat BBQ Sauce,  Meat Rub & Spicy Meat Rub. Damn, that's a great gift!
Rufus Teague RUB VARIETY PACK $29.45
All of Rufus's spices, in one package. Meat Rub, Spicy Meat Rub, Fish Rub, Steak Rub and our new Chick N' Rub. Everything you need to make lots of food gooder... for a long time.
Rufus Teague 3 PACK GIFT TOTE $20.95
Give someone the gift of Rufus. All nice and purdy in this cool little box. The Saucin' & Rubbin' Gift Tote includes: One Honey Sweet, One Touch O' Heat and One Meat Rub. Aren't you the nice one giving out something so special.
Rufus Teague BBQ NUTS - VARIETY 3 PACK $24.99
BOOM! Get all THREE varieties of Genuine BBQ Nuts. All are honey roasted and coated in Rufus’ legendary Honey Sweet BBQ goodness. Each comes in a stay-fresh pouch that’s resealable, as long as you can force yourself to stop eating long enough to zip it. You get: BBQ Peanuts, BBQ Almonds, BBQ Nut Mix.
Sold out
Rufus Teague SMOKE-ROASTED COFFEE - VARIETY PACK $44.99
Stock up on all FOUR flavors of delicious Smoke-Roasted coffee. That's a lot of java to get you up and going each and every day.  You'll get one bag each of PITMASTER BLEND,  WHISKEY MAPLE, SPICED CHERRY and SMOKY APPLE.  That's a lot of flavor, so get ready to brew up a pot, kick back and know what you're drinking is coffee, just gooder.   - MEDIUM GRIND - 2 Tbsp. + 6 oz of water = 1 dang good cup of joe!
Rufus Teague K-CUPS - SMOKE-ROASTED COFFEES (80 count) $49.99
Fancy! Now you can just pop in a pod and in no time have a delicious cup of smoke-roasted coffee. You get 80 K-Cups including 20 of each flavor: Pitmaster Blend, Whiskey Maple, Spiced Cherry & Smoky Apple.   Brew up a cup, kick back and know what you're drinking is coffee, just gooder.  
Rufus Teague SUNFLOWER SEEDS - VARIETY PACK $16.99
Stock up on all FOUR flavors of our amazing "Spittin' Seeds". You'll get a whole mess of our famous Rufus Teague BBQ flavor baked right into top-notch sunflower seeds. And each comes in a resealable, stay-fresh pouch that's perfect for camping, hunting, fishing, working outdoors and making your back pant pocket look cool.
Pepper Joe’s Reaper Meat and Cheese Bundle $23.99
What do you get when you combine the throat-burning sensation of our Carolina Reaper Summer Sausage with the cool and creamy spiciness of our Reaper Cheddar Cheese? One AMAZING spicy snack bundle, that's for sure! Our new Reaper Meat and Cheese Bundle takes both of our favorite Reaper pepper products and puts them together for one unforgettably spicy snack. Our Reaper Summer Sausage is made carefully to create the perfect blend of Midwestern meat with the bold flavors of our Carolina Reaper pepper flakes. Pair this fiery meat with our Reaper Cheddar Cheese, made with world-famous Wisconsin cheese and Reaper pepper flakes. Don't expect to give your taste buds a break! The unrelenting heat stays with every bite you take, but the amazing flavors will have you coming back for more. Enjoy these two together on a cracker, serve it up on a sandwich, or add this to a platter of other spicy pepper cheeses and spicy summer sausages. Bring our Reaper Meat and Cheese Bundle to your next cookout, gathering, or enjoy it all to yourself! Surprise your most daring pepper-lover friends with the snack bundle of the season - they won't regret it! We take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with ice packs to protect your shipment. Got Reaper Madness? Check out more of our Reaper products! Browse through our spicy gift baskets for great gift ideas.
Pepper Joe’s Reaper Mega Meat Gift Box $34.99
What's better than getting a box of delicious tender meats? How about getting a box of premium meats crafted with the World's Hottest Pepper! These tasty protein-filled snacks are not only made with premium Midwestern beef and pork but they're also packed with delicious mouth-melting Carolina Reaper heat. Just be warned, you'll want to eat these super spicy snacks faster than you probably should. This exclusive bundle of Carolina Reaper sausage, snack sticks, and jerky is the ultimate gift for a friend, family member, or yourself. Here's what's included: Carolina Reaper Summer Sausage (12oz) Carolina Reaper Snack Sticks (7oz) Carolina Reaper Beef Jerky Carolina Reaper Bacon Jerky Can't get enough of the Reaper? Browse all Reaper products.
THE PEPPER PANTRY | COPYRIGHT © 2025
FOLLOW US