Spicy Deals
-59% sale
Heartbeat Hot Sauce Red Habanero 6 oz. Best By/Best Buy January 2026
$5.00
$12.00
Heartbeat Hot Sauce is all about the peppers. They've taken the bold heat and flavor of red habaneros, the sweetness of bell peppers and the brightness of fresh lime juice to create the most versatile hot sauce possible. Fermented in small batches and entirely hand made without the use of thickening agents, preservatives or added water. Bring new life to all your favorite foods both savory and sweet.
Heat Index: 5 of 10
Size: 6 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Bell Pepper, Onion, White Vinegar, Sugar, Red Habanero, Garlic, Lime Juice, Kosher Salt, Canola Oil.
Gluten Free, Preservative Free, Vegan.
Made in Ontario, Canada
-24% sale
Historic Lynchburg Gobblin' Good Turkey Rub - 5 oz. Best By 4/30/26
$10.00
$13.00
The people of Lynchburg have been using dry rubs to enhance the flavor of their meats and vegetables before the turn of the century. Gobblin' Good Turkey Rub is an excellent dry rub seasoning for turkey, chicken, other fowl, vegetables and soups. Rub turkey with olive or vegetable oil and sprinkle seasoning liberally all over turkey inside and out. It's always good to rub a little between the turkey breast and skin along with a couple patties of butter. Then cook as you normally do.
Size: 5 oz.
Ingredients: Spice (Rosemary, Thyme, Sage, & Other Spices), Paprika, Turbanado Sugar, Kosher Salt, Lemon Peel, Garlic, Onion, Parsley, Jack Daniel's Black Label Whiskey.
Made in Lynchburg, Tennessee.
-31% sale
Historic Lynchburg Cinnamon Chipotle Seasoning - 5 oz. Best by 5/2025
$9.00
$13.00
These products are shelf stable, just like your grandma's canned goods. The will last well past their best by date, making them a best BUY!
The people of Lynchburg have been using dry rubs to enhance the flavor of their meats before the turn of the century. This is an excellent dry rub marinade for pork, pork ribs, pork chops and chicken. It is also an excellent seasoning sprinkled on sweet potatoes. Rub seasoning gently into meat covering thoroughly. For best results place rub on meat several hours or overnight before cooking.
Size: 5 oz.
Ingredients: Sugar, brown sugar, kosher salt, spices, cinnamon, Chipotle pepper, black pepper, onion, garlic, vinegar powder, Jack Daniel's Black Label Whiskey.
Made in Lynchburg, Tennessee.
-59% sale
Heartbeat Hot Sauce Jalapeno 6 oz. Best Buy/Best By 1/15/26
$5.00
$12.00
New to the Heartbeat Hot Sauce lineup, a slightly milder offering made with fresh jalapeno and fermented Serrano peppers to give that signature Heartbeat flavor and perfectly balanced heat. As with the original Red Habanero we've produced this without the use of any preservatives, thickening agents, extracts and NO ADDED WATER, giving you a pure and natural hot sauce that's all flavor and can be enjoyed on practically anything!
Heat Index: 4 of 10
Size: 6 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Jalapeno, Onion, Distilled Vinegar, Serrano Pepper, Sugar, Lime Juice, Garlic, Canola Oil, Salt, Cilantro
Made in Ontario, Canada
-59% sale
Historic Lynchburg Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning Best By 4/2025
$5.00
$12.00
These products are shelf stable like your grandma's canned goods! They will be good well past their best by date, making them a best BUY!
Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning is a sure fire way to get perfect Nashville chicken flavor every time.
Sprinkle all sides of chicken with seasoning. Mix 2 cups of all purpose flour with 1 tablespoon Tennessee Whiskey Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning, 1 tablespoon black pepper and 1 teaspoon salt. Dip 8 pieces of chicken in buttermilk, then dredge in seasoned flour and fry in a cast iron skillet in 4 cups of canola oil or lard. When done, remove chicken and mix in 2 tablespoons seasoning in hot oil and brush onto all sides of chicken. Serve with white bread and dill pickles!
-50% sale
Rich's Backyard Blackening Seasoning Best By/Best Buy 10/25
$6.50
$13.00
This seasoning delivers a delicious savory flavor with a kick of heat that adds zest to your recipes and gives your finicky tongue an exciting ride without burning. The formula is created by a certified MasterChef, ensuring the highest quality and taste. The Blackened Seasoning is a must-have pantry item. You don't need much for whatever you're seasoning; just a few shakes add a ton of flavor, making it perfect for seasoning chicken, seafood, pork, or beef.
Proudly Made in the USAProduced in the USA, our seasoning guarantees the highest quality and taste, offering big, bold flavors without additives, so you can enjoy the taste of your food without any adverse effects.
Ingredients: Spices (including paprika), Onion, Salt, Garlic, Contains 2% or less: Canola oil
-50% sale
Rich's Backyard Old School A.P. Rub Seasoning Best By/Best Buy 10/25
$6.50
$13.00
Introducing the Old School A.P. Rub, a must-have seasoning for grilling and smoking enthusiasts. This versatile spice blend adds depth and flavor to your grilled or smoked meats and vegetables, making it perfect for all-purpose seasoning. Whether you're a master chef or a novice cook, this rub elevates your dishes to gourmet levels.
Ingredients: Kosher Salt, Garlic, Black Pepper, Canola Oil
-65% sale
Heartbeat Poirier's Louisiana Style Hot Sauce 6 oz. Best By 9/2025
$5.00
$14.00
These sauces are shelf stable, like your grandma's canned goods. They will be tasty well past their best by date, making them a best BUY!
Dustin Poirier is bringing the heat! The UFC fan favorite has partnered with Heartbeat Hot Sauce to create Poirier's Louisiana Style, a hot sauce ode to his Lafayette, Louisiana roots. Like any good Cajun sauce, the recipe starts with the best cayenne peppers, fermented to round out the sting and up the flavor before finishing with vinegar, sea salt, celery and garlic. Add in a handful of red habaneros for an extra punch of heat, and you have a knock out sauce that can take on everything from heavyweight meals like biscuits and gravy to featherweight dishes like grilled chicken breast or cauliflower pizza.
Ingredients: Vinegar, aged cayenne peppers, sea salt, red habanero, celery, garlic, canola oil
Size: 6 FL oz
-54% sale
Historic Lynchburg Balsamic BBQ Sauce & Glaze - 16 oz. Best By 6/2025
$7.00
$15.00
This product is shelf stable, just like your grandma's canned goods, and will be good well past it's best by date, making it a best BUY!
It is a seductive, delicious culinary creation made with superior quality balsamic vinegar of Modena, Italy as well as other high quality ingredients and a splash of Tennessee Whiskey. It is a perfect balance between sweet and tangy with a syrupy texture. Drizzle on grilled, smoked or roasted meets and vegetables, chicken, fish, hamburgers, fries, cheese, fresh berries, or as a dipping or barbecue sauce. It's a perfect compliment to almost any food, sweet yet tangy, rich & aromatic.
Heat Index: 1 of 10
Size: 16 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Balsamic Vinegar of Modena, Tomato Concentrate, Brown Sugar, Worcestershire Sauce, Dijon Mustard, Salt, Garlic, Jack Daniel's Whiskey.
Made in Lynchburg, Tennessee.
Marie Sharp's Belizean Barbacoa Caribbean BBQ Sauce Best By 11/2024
$13.00
This product is shelf stable, like your grandma's canned goods and will last well past the best by date!
Belizean Barbacoa ticks all the boxes, offering a premium alternative to A1 steak sauce, HP brown sauce, or Jamaican PickaPeppa sauce. Based on Marie Sharp's Original Exotic Sauce recipe
"Marie Sharp's, Made in Belize, the former British Honduras. You were thinking of Grenada. Cooked up first in the kitchen by Marie and her family, now by 20 employees who are like family. No salt. No oil. A little spicy and and very delicious. Ingredients: fresh green mangoes, tamarind, raisins, ginger, sugar, vinegar, onions, garlic, Habanero peppers and spices.
Worcestershire and Marie Sharp's Exotic are the two best steak sauces in the world. Sometimes I get to the point where I add a little Worcestershire, Marie Sharp's or Saigon Sizzle to everything."
- Roger Ebert - November 1, 2008
https://www.rogerebert.com/roger-ebert/the-pot-and-how-to-use-it
Very mild on the heat index.
100% GLUTEN FREE | Better than A1, HP or PickaPeppa!
-66% sale
Historic Lynchburg Gobblin' Good Turkey Rub Pack of 4 Best By 4/30/26
$15.00
$43.00
Historic Lynchburg Gobblin' Good Turkey Rub Pack of 4
The people of Lynchburg have been using dry rubs to enhance the flavor of their meats and vegetables before the turn of the century. Gobblin' Good Turkey Rub is an excellent dry rub seasoning for turkey, chicken, other fowl, vegetables and soups. Rub turkey with olive or vegetable oil and sprinkle seasoning liberally all over turkey inside and out. It's always good to rub a little between the turkey breast and skin along with a couple patties of butter. Then cook as you normally do.
Size: 5 oz.
Ingredients: Spice (Rosemary, Thyme, Sage, & Other Spices), Paprika, Turbanado Sugar, Kosher Salt, Lemon Peel, Garlic, Onion, Parsley, Jack Daniel's Black Label Whiskey.
Made in Lynchburg, Tennessee.
-20% sale
Rufus Teague Spicy Steak Sauce Best by 3/1/25
$8.00
$10.00
Get ready for flavor that kicks like a mule. Sure, it fires up steak, but this zesty, savory, lip-smackingly delicious sauce will transform any meat into a top of the food chain delicacy. Prepare yourself for wanting more. And more. Thick and intense, this is not what most people think of when they hear steak sauce.
Ingredients: Water, Raisin Paste, Sugar, Distilled Vinegar, Tamarind, Soy Sauce (Water, Soybeans, Salt, Sugar), Tomato Paste, Habanero Pepper (Habanero Pepper, Salt, Acetic Acid), Spices (Including Mustard Powder), Anchovy Paste (Anchovies, Sea Salt, Water), Garlic Powder, Paprika, Dried Onion, Salt, Orange Juice (From Concentrate), Chipotle Pepper. Contains: Fish (Anchovies), Soy, Mustard.
-50% sale
Rich's Backyard Harissa Seasoning Best By/Best Buy 10/25
$6.50
$13.00
This seasoning can be used as a rub for meats, sprinkled atop roasted vegetables, popcorn, or french fries, stirred into broths, stews, and pasta, or mixed with sauces and spreads to add an explosion of flavor to your meals. Made with non-synthetic flavorings, this all-purpose seasoning is perfect for homemade cuisines, adding tangy goodness and spicy delight to your dishes.
Ingredients: Chili Peppers (including paprika), Spices, Onion, Brown Sugar, Salt, Garlic, Tomato Powder, Citric Acid, Contains less than 2% or less: Silicon Dioxide (Flow Agent)
Marie Sharp's Belizean Barbacoa BBQ Sauce Smokin' Hot Best By 11/2024
from $13.00
This product is shelf stable, just like your grandma's canned goods! It will be good well past it's best by date, making this a best BUY!
Think A1, HP or Pickapeppa + Smokey Heat!
Hand-picked fresh green Haden mangoes, cane sugar, natural vinegar, fresh pureed tamarind, Worcestershire sauce, hand chopped white onion, smoked habanero peppers, raisins, fresh ginger, sea salt, fresh garlic, spices.
Belizean Barbacoa ticks all the boxes, offering a premium alternative to A1 steak sauce, HP brown sauce, or Jamaican PickaPeppa sauce. Based on Marie Sharp's Original Exotic Sauce recipe.
"Marie Sharp's, Made in Belize, the former British Honduras. You were thinking of Grenada. Cooked up first in the kitchen by Marie and her family, now by 20 employees who are like family. No salt. No oil. A little spicy and and very delicious. Ingredients: fresh green mangoes, tamarind, raisins, ginger, sugar, vinegar, onions, garlic, Habanero peppers and spices.
Worcestershire and Marie Sharp's Exotic are the two best steak sauces in the world. Sometimes I get to the point where I add a little Worcestershire, Marie Sharp's or Saigon Sizzle to everything."
- Roger Ebert - November 1, 2008
https://www.rogerebert.com/roger-ebert/the-pot-and-how-to-use-it
100% GLUTEN FREE | Better than A1, HP or PickaPeppa!
Smoky and Spicy
-20% sale
Historic Lynchburg Flapjack & Waffle Honey Maple Syrup Best By/Best Buy 9/15/2025
$12.00
$15.00
In their search for a distinctive flavor for Flapjacks and Waffles, the old folks realized that local Tennessee Whiskey was the answer. The family is proud of their delicious syrup and committed to providing the finest traditional old-time quality available. This syrup is delicious drizzled over hot, buttered, golden brown flapjacks and waffles.
Heat Index: 1 of 10
Size: 16 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Corn Syrup, Sugar, Pure Maple Syrup, Honey, Flavoring, Jack Daniel's Whiskey, and Sodium Benzoate.
Made in Lynchburg, Tennessee.
-48% sale
Rich’s Backyard Complete Seasoning & Rub Set – Pack of 5 (9oz Each) Best By/Buy 10/25
$34.00
$65.00
Complete Set of 5 Gourmet Seasonings & Rubs – Includes a versatile collection of expertly blended seasonings, each crafted for grilling, smoking, roasting, and everyday cooking
Perfect for Chicken, Beef, Pork, Seafood & Wild Game – Whether you're preparing steaks; ribs; brisket; seafood; or vegetables, these rubs deliver rich, bold flavor to every dish
All-Natural Ingredients, No MSG or Preservatives – Made with premium herbs and spices, this seasoning set is 100% natural, free from artificial additives, and designed for clean, high-quality flavor.
Versatile & Easy to Use – Cook Like a Master Chef – Simply rub, season, or sprinkle onto meats and vegetables before grilling; roasting; pan-searing; or slow cooking for exceptional results
The Ultimate Gift for BBQ Lovers & Home Chefs – A gourmet spice set that makes the perfect gift for foodies, grill masters, and home cooks who love authentic, chef-approved flavors
-25% sale
Historic Lynchburg Lemon Pepper & Herb Seasoning - 4.1 oz. Best by 7/2025
$9.00
$12.00
These products are shelf stable, like your grandma's canned goods. They will last well past their best by date, making them a best BUY!
The people of Lynchburg have been using seasonings to enhance the flavor of their meats since before the turn of the century. This is an excellent herb seasoning marinade for smoking, grilling, frying or oven roasting chicken, fish, pork, vegetables, or soups. Rub seasoning gently into meat covering all areas thoroughly. For best results rub seasonings on meat several hours to overnight before cooking. Goes Great With: fish, chicken, pastas, soups, and vegetables.
Size: 4.1 oz.
Ingredients: Black Pepper, Kosher Salt, Lemon Peel, Sugar, Lemon Juice Powder, Garlic, Onion, Citric Acid, Spices (Rosemary, Basil, Oregano, and others) Natural Flavor & Jack Daniel's Black Label Whiskey.
Made in Lynchburg, Tennessee.
-50% sale
Rich's Backyard South Shore Seasoning Best By/Best Buy 10/25
$6.50
$13.00
Revamp your ordinary meals by incorporating Rich's Backyard South Shore Vegetable & Seafood Seasoning. Ideal for seafood, pork, poultry, beef, and vegetable dishes. Produced in the USA for top-notch quality and flavor, this seasoning delivers bold taste without additives, letting you savor your food without any drawbacks.
Ingredients: Spices (including paprika), Salt, Celery seed, Mustard seed
Marie Sharp's Grapefruit Pulp Habanero Sauce Gallon Best By/ Best Buy July 2025
$35.00
This product is shelf stable, just like your grandma's canned goods! It will last well past the best by date!
Similar to Yuzu flavored sauces from Japan, Marie Sharp's citrus-inspired habanero pepper sauces have bright Tropical notes.
Freshly squeezed Grapefruit pulp, yellow Belizean habanero pepper, natural vinegar, hand chopped white onions, sea salt, freshly squeezed key lime juice, and fresh garlic - Mindfully made in Belize, Central America.
-50% sale
Marie Sharp's Grapefruit Pulp Habanero Sauce Gallon Best By/ Best Buy December 2024
$35.00
$69.99
This product is shelf stable, just like your grandma's canned goods! It will last well past the best by date!
Similar to Yuzu flavored sauces from Japan, Marie Sharp's citrus-inspired habanero pepper sauces have bright Tropical notes.
Freshly squeezed Grapefruit pulp, yellow Belizean habanero pepper, natural vinegar, hand chopped white onions, sea salt, freshly squeezed key lime juice, and fresh garlic - Mindfully made in Belize, Central America.
-42% sale
Rich's Backyard Seasoning Three Pack Best By/Best Buy 10/25
$23.00
$39.00
Blackening Seasoning: This seasoning delivers a delicious savory flavor with a kick of heat that adds zest to your recipes and gives your finicky tongue an exciting ride without burning. The formula is created by a certified MasterChef, ensuring the highest quality and taste. The Blackened Seasoning is a must-have pantry item. You don't need much for whatever you're seasoning; just a few shakes add a ton of flavor, making it perfect for seasoning chicken, seafood, pork, or beef.
Ingredients: Spices (including paprika), Onion, Salt, Garlic, Contains 2% or less: Canola oil
Old School A.P. Rub: Introducing the Old School A.P. Rub, a must-have seasoning for grilling and smoking enthusiasts. This versatile spice blend adds depth and flavor to your grilled or smoked meats and vegetables, making it perfect for all-purpose seasoning. Whether you're a master chef or a novice cook, this rub elevates your dishes to gourmet levels.
Ingredients: Kosher Salt, Garlic, Black Pepper, Canola Oil
Bayou Cajun Seasoning
Ideal for seasoning beef, chicken, pork, seafood, wild game, vegetables, and popcorn, our Cajun Seasoning brings a fun twist to your dishes and is perfect for weekend cookouts. Using non-synthetic flavorings, our seasoning adds a tangy kick and spicy delight to your homemade meals, ensuring everyone will enjoy the flavors.
Proudly Made in the USA Produced in the USA, our seasoning guarantees the highest quality and taste, offering big, bold flavors without additives, so you can enjoy the taste of your food without any adverse effects.
Copyright ©2025. The Pepper Pantry. All Rights Reserved.