Sold out
Trappiste Ale-Washed Gouda $18.00
Description Shipping Ingredients Tapped in local chocolate stout that traces back to Belgian monks, this Gouda is brewing with hints of malt and yeast, deepening as it ages. Another collaboration with the artisan cheesemakers at Door Artisan Cheese in Egg Harbor, Wisconsin, this limited run edition is available while supplies last! Note: Trappiste may contain trace amounts of gluten from the ale used in production   Net weight: 5 oz.Origin: Egg Harbor, WIAge: 6 months +Flavor: Rich, nutty, and caramelly, with hints of chocolate and dark ale. Pair with: Dark chocolate, blackberries, pretzels, dark ales and beers.  Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, animal-derived rennet.
Sold out
*Limited Edition* Door County Duet $17.00
Description Shipping Ingredients We worked with our friends at Door Artisan Cheese to produce a true Wisconsin original: Door County Duet. This cheese harmonizes the essence of aged gouda with rich and nutty Parmesan to create a beautiful melody of flavor. We produced 500 pounds of this original last year. After months of patient curing, it is ready to ship today. Buy yours while supplies last! Net weight: 5 oz.Origin: Egg Harbor, WIAge: 6 months +Flavor: Rich and nutty with hints of caramel. Pair with: Cabernet Sauvignon, charcuterie boards, fruit Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, animal-derived rennet.
sale
Tomato Basil Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily* from $8.95
Description Shipping Ingredients For fresh flavor, you won't find better than these made to order Wisconsin cheese curds with garden fresh tomato and basil. Every day we ship a limited quantity of these Tomato Basil cheese curds nationwide. Curds are a Wisconsin staple, known for their fresh, addicting taste and springy texture that "squeaks" when you bite into them. These are garnished with tomato and basil for an added bonus of fresh, verdant flavor. Pro tip: microwave for a few seconds before eating for an authentic "fresh from the vat" taste!  For best taste and texture, enjoy or freeze within a week of delivery.  Net weight: 8 oz.Origin: Northern WisconsinAge: Freshly made-to-orderFlavor: Reminiscent of fresh mozzarella or string cheese with a springy texture, seasoned with fresh basil and tomatoes. Best for: An addicting snack or garnish for pizzas, soups, and more.  Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect Ingredients: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Tomato, and Basil.
sale
Garlic and Dill Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily* from $8.95
Description Shipping Ingredients Get them while they last! Every day we ship a limited quantity of these fresh garlic and dill cheese curds nationwide. Curds are a Wisconsin staple, known for their fresh, addicting taste and springy texture that "squeaks" when you bite into them. These are garnished with garlic and dill for an added burst of herbaceous flavor. Pro tip: microwave for a few seconds before eating for an authentic "fresh from the vat" taste!  For best taste and texture, enjoy or freeze within a week of delivery.  Net weight: 6 oz.Origin: Northern WisconsinAge: Freshly made-to-orderFlavor: Reminiscent of fresh mozzarella or string cheese with a springy texture, with garlic and dill. Best for: An addicting snack Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, garlic seasoning (granulated garlic and dill weed).
The Char-CURD-erie Box $69.95
Description Shipping Ingredients For a delicious cheese and meat spread without the prep, our Char-CURD-erie Box always delivers. Packed with freshly made to order Wisconsin cheese curds, classic summer sausage, and locally made Cherry Lavender jam, this delightful assortment is the perfect spread to impress at your next game day or holiday gathering. No slicing necessary. Just open and serve! Never tried a cheese curd? These tasty morsels are a Wisconsin staple, known for their fresh taste and springy texture that "squeaks" when you eat them. Ours are made fresh daily in an array of original flavors. Secure yours today for cold pack shipping direct to your door! Contents: Three 8 oz. bags of freshly made to order Wisconsin cheese curds (Tomato Basil, Bloody Mary, and Hot Pepper). Two 6 oz. bag of freshly made to order Wisconsin cheese curds (Classic, and Garlic Dill) Two 8 oz. Barron Sausage Co. summer sausages  One 8 oz. jar of Cherry Lavender Jam from Bushel and Peck of Beloit, Wisconsin. *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged. Ingredients Classic: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Garlic Dill: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, garlic seasoning (granulated garlic and dill weed). Bloody Mary: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto(Color), Tomatoes, Hot Bloody Mary Spice (Salt, Spices, Maltodextrin, Onion & Garlic Powder, Worcestershire Sauce [Vinegar, Molasses, CornSyrup, Salt, Garlic Powder, Caramel Color, Sugar, Spices, Tamarind, Natural Flavor], Dextrose, Extractives of Turmeric, Natural Flavors, Less Than 2% Silicon Dioxide(prevents caking)). Tomato Basil: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Tomato, and Basil. Ranch: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Ranch Seasoning (Maltodextrin, Buttermilk, Salt, Monosodium Glutamate, Dried Garlic, Dried Onion, Lactic Acid, Calcium Lactate, Spices, Citric Acid, Less Than 1% of: Calcium Stearate, Artificial Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Carboxymethyl cellulose, Guar Gum, Natural Flavors). Barron Sausage Co. Summer Sausage: Beef, salt, dextrose, spices, sugar, lactic acid starter culture, sodium ascorbate, sodium nitrite. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
sale
Wisconsin Cheese Curds *Ships Fresh Daily* from $8.95
Description Shipping Ingredients Get them while they last! Everyday we ship a limited quantity of fresh Wisconsin cheese curds to customers nationwide. These tasty morsels are a Wisconsin staple, known for their fresh, addicting taste and springy texture that "squeaks" when you bite into them. Pro tip: microwave for a few seconds before eating for an authentic "fresh from the vat" taste!  For best taste and texture, enjoy or freeze within a week of delivery.  Net weight: 6 oz.Origin: Northern WisconsinAge: Freshly made-to-orderFlavor: Reminiscent of fresh mozzarella or string cheese with a springy textureBest for: An addicting snack Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes.
Jalapeño Pepper Cheese Spread *New Release* $9.95
Description Shipping Ingredients This spicy (but not too spicy!) cheese spread is the perfect addictive snack to put out for gatherings or enjoy as a flavorful snack on your own. Made using real cheese and jalapeños in our facility in Almena, Wisconsin, this artisan creation is the real deal. Enjoy with pretzels, crackers, or spread on corn on the cob (trust us, it's really good!).  Net weight: 8 oz. Origin: Almena, WisconsinFlavor: Spicy, sharp and savoryPair with: Crackers, pretzels, and spread on fresh corn on the cob Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this box as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions. Ingredients Sharp cheddar cold pack cheese food (cheddar cheese [pasteurized cultured milk, salt, enzymes], water, reduced lactose whey, cream, whey, sorbic acid [to prevent mold], sea salt, lactic acid, guar gum, annatto color), cream cheese (pasteurized milk and cream, cheese culture, salt, stabilizers [carob bean, xanthan, guar gums]), mayonnaise (soybean oil, water, egg yolks, distilled white vinegar, eggs, contains less than 2% of: high fructose corn syrup, salt, natural flavor, mustard flour, calcium disodium edta [to preserve flavor, paprika), jalapeños (jalapeño peppers, water, vinegar, salt, calcium chloride), garlic, onion, sorbic acid (preservative). CONTAINS: Milk, eggs. Made in a facility that handles wheat, soy, eggs, milk and tree nuts.
Deluxe Game Day Essentials Gift Pack $79.95
Get game day ready with this deluxe snackable collection of savory treats from Cheese Brothers. We packed in everything you'll need to entertain your guests for the Big Game, including an assortment of Wisconsin cheeses, summer sausage from our very own Barron Sausage Co., and our most snackable item of all: our squeaky fresh Wisconsin cheese curds. Contents: Two 6 oz. blocks of Wisconsin-made cheese (3 Amigos Gouda and Smoked Gouda) One 6 oz. bags of original squeaky fresh Wisconsin cheese curds One 6 oz. bag of fresh made to order garlic dill cheese curds One 5 oz. block of our delightfully sharp 8-Year Aged Cheddar One 8 oz. jar of Bier Hall Mustard from PS Seasonings of Iron Ridge, WI Two 8 oz. summer sausages from our own Barron Sausage Co.  One 5 oz. package of Classic White organic crackers from Potter's Crackers of Madison, Wisconsin
    *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page. Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged. Ingredients 3 Amigos Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, jalapeno, habanero, chipotle peppers, annatto coloring. Fratello: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Smoked Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. 8-Year-Aged Cheddar: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
15-Year-Aged Cheddar $23.95
Description Shipping Ingredients This aged sharp cheddar cheese is only available while supplies last! After a decade and a half waiting, we've released our most complex – and sharp – cheddar cheese, to-date.  When you try this 15-year-aged cheddar you should expect rich, intense flavors and a firm, though sometimes crumbly texture, thanks to its extended curing time. Our aged sharp cheddar cheese doesn’t blend in with the crowd. Enjoy all 15 years of the aging process by eating this on its own or with a light pairing of dried fruit or fresh apples. Net weight: 5 oz.Origin: Kiel, WisconsinAge: 15 yearsFlavor: Very sharp, nutty, tangy, richPair with: Cabernet Sauvignon, charcuterie boards, fruit Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes.
"Have a Cheesy Birthday" Gift Basket $69.95
Description Shipping Ingredients Celebrate another trip around the sun with this colorful collection of tasty cheeses from Wisconsin. The old blends with the new in this collection, with traditional flavors like our famous cold smoked gouda side by side with Fratello, our original Italian-style blend. Spice lovers will find plenty to love as well. The perfect birthday gift for the cheese enthusiast! Contents: Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.  Eight 6 oz. blocks of artisan Wisconsin cheese (Dill Havarti, 3 Amigos Gouda, Honey Sriracha Gouda, Smoked Mozzarella, Scorpion Pepper Gouda, Smoked Gouda, Fratello (an original, meltable Italian blend), and Mango Habanero Gouda "Have a Cheesy Birthday" sticker on box   Pictured cupcake not included. Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page. Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged. Ingredients Dill Havarti: Cultured pasteurized milk, dill, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. Sharp Cheddar: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Smoked Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. Fratello: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
"Precious Cargo" Horseradish Cheddar $8.95
The pungent personality of this cheddar carts a potent kick that's a wild ride even for adventurous eaters. A rambling wanderer all its own, it's easy to hitch onto Precious Cargo Horseradish Cheddar for an escape from the mundane. Spice up a sandwich or garnish the ultimate Bloody Mary to incorporate that telltale horseradish bite.  Net weight: 6 oz.Origin: Stanley, WisconsinAge: 2 - 12 monthsFlavor: Creamy and buttery with a horseradish kickBest for: Sandwiches, grilled cheese, meat and cheese boards
-10% sale
Deluxe Char-CURD-erie Box $112.95 $124.95
Description Shipping Ingredients Looking for an abundant and impressive meat and cheese board without the prep work? Look no further than our Deluxe Char-CURD-erie Box. This collection is packed with all nine of our freshly made to order, bite sized Wisconsin cheese curds, our very own Barron Sausage Co. summer sausage, and an assortment of artisan treats from local producers. No slicing or other work needed. Just open and serve at your next holiday or game day gathering! Never tried a cheese curd? These tasty morsels are a Wisconsin staple, known for their fresh taste and springy texture that "squeaks" when you eat them. Ours are made fresh daily in an array of original flavors. Secure yours today for cold pack shipping direct to your door! Contents: Four 8 oz. bags of squeaky fresh Wisconsin cheese curds (Tomato Basil, Hot Pepper, Jamaican Jerk, and Bloody Mary) Five 6 oz. bags of squeaky fresh Wisconsin cheese curds (Classic, Garlic Dill, Ranch, Cajun and Buffalo Wing) Two 8 oz. Barron Sausage Co. summer sausages  One 8 oz. jar of Cherry Lavender Jam from Bushel and Peck of Beloit, Wisconsin. One 7 oz. jar of hand-made Bier Hall Stone Ground Mustard One 5 oz. package of Classic White organic crackers from Potter's Crackers of Madison, Wisconsin  *If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.  Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge. *Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged. Ingredients Classic: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes. Garlic Dill: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, garlic seasoning (granulated garlic and dill weed). Bloody Mary: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto(Color), Tomatoes, Hot Bloody Mary Spice (Salt, Spices, Maltodextrin, Onion & Garlic Powder, Worcestershire Sauce [Vinegar, Molasses, CornSyrup, Salt, Garlic Powder, Caramel Color, Sugar, Spices, Tamarind, Natural Flavor], Dextrose, Extractives of Turmeric, Natural Flavors, Less Than 2% Silicon Dioxide(prevents caking)). Cajun: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, garlic seasoning (granulated garlic and dill weed). Hot Pepper: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto (Color), Hot Pepper Spice (Spices, Salt, Sugar, Dried Garlic, Dried Jalapeño. Jamaican Jerk: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Jamaican Jerk Seasoning (Spices, Sugar, Salt, Paprika, Vinegar Flavor [Sodium Diacetate, Natural Flavor], Canola Oil, Contains 2% or Less of Garlic, Onion, Caramel Color, Citric Acid, Silicon Dioxide (anti-caking agent), Turmeric). Tomato Basil: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Tomato, and Basil. Buffalo Wing: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Buffalo Wing Seasoning (Spices, Dried Hot Sauce, [Aged Cayenne Red Peppers, Vinegar, Salt, Garlic], Natural Butter Flavor, Maltodextrin, Tomato Powder, Dried Onion, Dextrose, Dried Chicken Broth, Distilled Vinegar, Modified Food Starch). Ranch: Cultured Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Enzymes, Ranch Seasoning (Maltodextrin, Buttermilk, Salt, Monosodium Glutamate, Dried Garlic, Dried Onion, Lactic Acid, Calcium Lactate, Spices, Citric Acid, Less Than 1% of: Calcium Stearate, Artificial Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Carboxymethyl cellulose, Guar Gum, Natural Flavors). Barron Sausage Co. Summer Sausage: Beef, salt, dextrose, spices, sugar, lactic acid starter culture, sodium ascorbate, sodium nitrite. Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
THE PEPPER PANTRY | COPYRIGHT © 2025
FOLLOW US