BBQ SAUCES
-54% sale
Historic Lynchburg Balsamic BBQ Sauce & Glaze - 16 oz. Best By 6/2025
$7.00
$15.00
This product is shelf stable, just like your grandma's canned goods, and will be good well past it's best by date, making it a best BUY!
It is a seductive, delicious culinary creation made with superior quality balsamic vinegar of Modena, Italy as well as other high quality ingredients and a splash of Tennessee Whiskey. It is a perfect balance between sweet and tangy with a syrupy texture. Drizzle on grilled, smoked or roasted meets and vegetables, chicken, fish, hamburgers, fries, cheese, fresh berries, or as a dipping or barbecue sauce. It's a perfect compliment to almost any food, sweet yet tangy, rich & aromatic.
Heat Index: 1 of 10
Size: 16 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Balsamic Vinegar of Modena, Tomato Concentrate, Brown Sugar, Worcestershire Sauce, Dijon Mustard, Salt, Garlic, Jack Daniel's Whiskey.
Made in Lynchburg, Tennessee.
3 PACK GIFT TOTE
$20.95
Give someone the gift of Rufus. All nice and purdy in this cool little box. The Saucin' & Rubbin' Gift Tote includes: One Honey Sweet, One Touch O' Heat and One Meat Rub. Aren't you the nice one giving out something so special.
-6% sale
Angi's Barbecue Sauce | Pack of 3 | 18 oz | Gluten Free | Brenmar
$19.92
$20.97
Known as the Midwest's Finest, the Angi's Barbecue Sauce recipe was created from good Ole Southern Love for barbecue and passion for blues music. Sweet and spicy barbecue sauce-a little goes a long way. This thick smoky sauce is perfect for slathering on smoked meats or just basting while you barbecue.
No high fructose corn syrup
No MSG
Gluten Free
18 oz. bottle
Sold and distributed by The Brenmar Company INC in La, Vista Nebraska.
BBQ SAUCE VARIETY PACK
$37.75
All of Rufus's sauce goodness in one package! A bottle of Honey Sweet, Touch O' Heat, Blazin' Hot, Whiskey Maple, Smoky Apple and K.C. Gold.
BLAZIN' HOT BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
Get the extinguisher ready cuz this sauce ain’t messing around. Blazin’ Hot is thick and sweet just like a great Kansas City BBQ sauce should be, only it finishes with a delicious burn that you won’t soon forget. While this sauce is specifically made for those that like a ton of spice, it’s still balanced with a ton of sweet, smoky flavor that Rufus is known for.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. As with all Rufus Teague sauces, we cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, Blazin’ Hot has a classic tomato base and is sweetened with real sugar and molasses. A myriad of peppers gives it enough heat that you’ll be wanting to cool down with another bite. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
DIABLO LIMONAJO BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
Diablo Limonajo (aka: Spicy Lemon Garlic) is a true fusion of Midwestern BBQ and authentic Hispanic flair. This unique and vibrant sauce is packed with heat and zesty spice thanks to a blend of lemon, garlic, cayenne and hatch chiles. All complimented by Rufus' traditional BBQ sweetness.
Diablo Limonajo is as at home on shrimp, poultry and pork as it is on fruits and vegetables. Also makes an amazing addition to drinks and cocktails.
As with all Rufus sauces, this is the real deal, not some cheap junk. We cook them down so the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, Diablo Limonajo has real garlic puree, citrus, hatch chile, lemon and is sweetened with real sugar. Get ready for some big, spicy, tongue fun.
Ghost Pepper Ketchup
from $9.99
If you’re like us, the world-famous Ghost Pepper is near the top of your favorite super-hot peppers list. Now we have yet another way to make the amazingly delicious Ghost Pepper part of your daily culinary routine – Ketchup! Our Ghost Ketchup is made from delicious ingredients and brings BIG heat and even BIGGER flavor.
Just like your old favorite ketchup, you can use our Ghost Ketchup on just about anything and everything. Just make sure you grab extras because you’ll have a tough time putting this one down.
Bottle Size: 14 oz
Heat Level: 7.5/10
Ingredients: Tomato concentrate (water, tomato paste), sugar, vinegar, sea salt, hickory smoke (water, hickory smoke flavor), bourbon, ghost chile powder, spices, flavor.
Want to grow these peppers yourself? Buy Ghost Pepper Seeds or skip the germination process and buy Ghost Pepper Live Plants here!
Be sure to check out our other Ghost Pepper products: Ghost Pepper Hot Sauce, Ghost Pepper BBQ Sauce, Ghost Pepper Dried Pods, Smoked Ghost Pepper Powder, and of course Ghost Pepper Seeds.
HONEY SWEET BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
Rufus Teague’s first sauce and still the most popular of all. Honey Sweet has been winning awards nearly since the day it was concocted. Thick, rich and smoky sweet. This classic Kansas City barbecue sauce is absolutely loaded with real honey and perfect for grillin’, dippin’ or drinkin’ straight out of the bottle.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. As with all Rufus Teague sauces, we cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest ingredients, our sauce is Gluten-free, Kosher and Non-GMO verified. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
KC GOLD BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
The bar for gold BBQ sauces has just been raised. Rufus’ Midwestern take on this tangy southern classic adds a little more sweet, smoky goodness to the traditional mustard flavor. And with a hint of bacon, it’ll have your taste buds singing.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. As with all Rufus Teague sauces, we cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, our sauce has a solid mustard base and sweetened with real sugar. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
Rufus Teague Blazin Hot BBQ Sauce
$8.00
Get the extinguisher ready cuz this sauce ain't messing around. Blazin Hot is thick and sweet just like a great Kansas City BBQ sauce should be, only it finishes with a delicious burn that you won't soon forget. While this sauce is specifically made for those that like a ton of spice, it's still balanced with a ton of sweet, smoky flavor that Rufus is known for.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. As with all Rufus Teague sauces, we cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, Blazin Hot has a classic tomato base and is sweetened with real sugar and molasses. A myriad of peppers gives it enough heat that you'll be wanting to cool down with another bite. So, make your food happy and remember, Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.
-20% sale
Rufus Teague Spicy Steak Sauce Best by 3/1/25
$8.00
$10.00
Get ready for flavor that kicks like a mule. Sure, it fires up steak, but this zesty, savory, lip-smackingly delicious sauce will transform any meat into a top of the food chain delicacy. Prepare yourself for wanting more. And more. Thick and intense, this is not what most people think of when they hear steak sauce.
Ingredients: Water, Raisin Paste, Sugar, Distilled Vinegar, Tamarind, Soy Sauce (Water, Soybeans, Salt, Sugar), Tomato Paste, Habanero Pepper (Habanero Pepper, Salt, Acetic Acid), Spices (Including Mustard Powder), Anchovy Paste (Anchovies, Sea Salt, Water), Garlic Powder, Paprika, Dried Onion, Salt, Orange Juice (From Concentrate), Chipotle Pepper. Contains: Fish (Anchovies), Soy, Mustard.
SAUCIN' & RUBBIN' KIT (4 pack)
$26.95
Give someone the gift of Rufus. All dolled up in this cool little box. You get one of each: Honey Sweet BBQ Sauce, Touch O' Heat BBQ Sauce, Meat Rub & Spicy Meat Rub. Damn, that's a great gift!
SLIM N' SWEET - Sugar Free
from $7.99
The perfect way to indulge in delicious Kansas City BBQ without worrying about sugar. This sweet and tangy sauce is the health-conscious way to curb those barbecue cravings. Whether diabetic, on Keto or just cutting back on sugar, this is the way to get all the flavor you want and feel good about it.
As with all Rufus Teague sauces Slim N’ Sweet is made with the finest natural ingredients. Sweetened with health-minded, all-natural Stevia and no sucralose or other artificial sweeteners. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
SMOKE 'N CHIPOTLE - Sugar Free
from $7.99
Not only has Rufus Teague made a rich, sweet BBQ sauce with the undeniable smoky heat of chipotle peppers, but all this flavor comes with absolutely NO sugar. For those that like their barbecue with a good amount of spice and zero added sugar, this one’s for you.
As with all Rufus Teague sauces Smoke ‘N Chipotle is made with the finest natural ingredients. Sweetened with health-minded, all-natural Stevia and no sucralose or other artificial sweeteners. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
SMOKE IN A BOTTLE
from $4.95
This ain't that nasty ol' liquid smoke that your mamma used to pour on pot roast. Nope, this little bottle is filled with genuine Rufus Teague barbecue flavor, legendary spices and the perfect amount of natural hickory smoke. It's sure to bring out the best in whatever meat or veggie you put it on. And yes... even pot roast.
SMOKY APPLE BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
Enjoy the thick, rich flavors of Kansas City barbecue with a new twist… APPLE! This unique sauce will liven up any dish with a kick of tangy apple to complement its sweet and smoky goodness.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. As with all Rufus Teague sauces, we cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, our sauce has a classic tomato-base and sweetened with real sugar and molasses. Just the right amount of apple juice gives it a great, fruity taste. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
SPICY STEAK SAUCE
from $6.75
Get ready for flavor that kicks like a mule. Sure, it fires up steak, but this zesty, savory, lip-smackingly delicious sauce will transform any meat into a top of the food chain delicacy. Prepare yourself for wanting more. And more. Thick and intense, this is not what most people think of when they hear ‘steak sauce’.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. Made with the finest ingredients, our sauce is Gluten-free, Kosher and Non-GMO verified. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
STEAK SAUCE
from $6.75
Finally, a steak sauce that lives up to… steak. Thick and zesty with tons of savory flavor. So go ahead, pour it on and rest easy knowing you’re making every piece of meat you put it on somehow even better. Unique and bold, this steak sauce that differs widely from the more well-known, watery condiments.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. Made with the finest ingredients, our sauce is Gluten-free, Kosher and Non-GMO verified. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
The BIG 3 BBQ Sauces
$21.45
Our three best selling BBQ Sauces all together in one package. It's a sweet and smoky dream come true. Each of these are real fan favorites and guaranteed to make barbecue believers out of anybody you feed them to. You get one bottle each of legendary Honey Sweet, kinda hot Touch O' Heat, and bold and boozy Whiskey Maple. So, go ahead and set this trio out at your next meal and watch the gang go wild!
TOUCH O' HEAT BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
Kinda hot. Kinda not. This smoky, sweet, Kansas City barbecue sauce has just enough spice to make your taste buds jump into action. A Rufus Teague fan favorite, this is the go-to sauce for many competition BBQ teams and restaurants since it is packed with flavor and just the right amount of spice.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. As with all Rufus Teague sauces, we cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, our sauce has a classic tomato-base and sweetened with real sugar and molasses. Chipotle pepper gives it just the right amount of kick. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
Trelawny Red | Smoked & Spicy BBQ Sauce | 8 oz. Bottle | Jamaican-Inspired | You Buy, We Give 100% | Mystic Rhoads Productions
$6.99
Discover daring and delicious flavor with Dirt Nap Dip Original Blend Hot Sauce! This 8 oz. bottle packs a punch with its intense habanero-infused burn and exotic Jamaican-inspired flavor. Go beyond ordinary and surprise your taste buds with the perfect 'zing' of spicy goodness that will have your mouth begging for more. Traditional recipes like chicken and pork can be elevated to the next level with a single pour of original blend Dirt Nap Dip. Join in the fun - you buy and we give 100%! #hotandspicy
8 oz. Glass Bottle
Purchase With A Purpose:
Sales from this product support the baldorf Charitable Foundation. The Foundation supports local communities through initiatives focusing on education, healthy lifestyles and environmental conservation. We're no ordinary charitable organization. Yes, we rely on donations, grants and community support. But, we like to make things happen on our own too. That's why we've created a line of products that funnel profits back to charitable causes. You buy, and we give. 100%.
Mystic Rhoads Productions is proudly owned and operated in Lincoln, Nebraska.
TRES CHILES PICA DULCE BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
Tres Chiles Pica Dulce essentially means Three Peppers with Sweet Heat. And that's just what it is. A true fusion of Midwestern BBQ and authentic Hispanic flair. This unique and decadent sauce is packed with flavor thanks to a blend of chipotle, arbol and hatch peppers mixed with zesty lime.
This is a whole new idea on how BBQ sauce can be reimagined through the lens of genuine Latino flavors. We wanted something that mixed authentically deep, smoky and bitter chili pepper flavors with the sweetness that Midwest BBQ sauces are known for. And that's just what we made.
Try it on everything from grilled or slow-cooked meat, to tacos and nachos or even as a your new favorite topper for a burger.
As with all Rufus sauces, this is the real deal, not some cheap junk. We cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, Tres Chiles Pica Dulce has a genuine ground peppers mixed with citrus and lightly sweetened with real sugar. A myriad of peppers gives it enough heat that you’ll be wanting to cool down with another bite.
WHISKEY MAPLE BBQ SAUCE
from $7.99
Old Rufus liked his whiskey, so he whipped up this sauce using real maple syrup and some of his favorite hooch. It has a fine boozy sweetness that’s perfect for barbecuing. The combination of whiskey and maple reduce down to make one intense flavor.
This is the real deal, not some cheap knockoff. As with all Rufus Teague sauces, we cook them longer, so they are less watery, and the flavor is more intense. Made with the finest natural ingredients, Whiskey Maple has a classic tomato-base and is sweetened with real sugar and molasses for a deep and distinguished taste. So, make your food happy and remember, “Good sauce makes bad barbecue good and good barbecue gooder.”
Copyright ©2026. The Pepper Pantry. All Rights Reserved.