CHEESES
-16% sale
The Ultimate Wisconsin Cheese Sampler
$105.95
$124.95
Description
Shipping
Ingredients
Can't decide which Cheese Brothers cheese to buy? We've got you! This king-sized assortment contains every cheese we carry, from classics like our Smoked Gouda to our mouth-watering 8-Year Aged Cheddar. Perfect for your next large gathering or for your own personal stockpile. Concerned about committing to this much cheese? Don't worry! All of our cheeses last well over a year sealed in the refrigerator.
Contents:
Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.
Fifteen 6 oz. blocks of Wisconsin cheese (honey sriracha gouda, dill havarti, smoked gouda, el diablo scorpion pepper gouda, 3 amigos spicy gouda, mango habanero Gouda, havarti, smoked mozzarella, sharp cheddar, smoked cheddar, Adelheid, Bourbon Gouda, smoked provolone, fratello, classic Gouda)
One 5 oz. block of Cheese Brothers Reserve cheese (8-Year-Aged Cheddar)
*If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.
Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page.
Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge.
*Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged.
Ingredients: See individual products for their ingredient information.
"Have a Cheesy Birthday" Gift Basket
$69.95
Description
Shipping
Ingredients
Celebrate another trip around the sun with this colorful collection of tasty cheeses from Wisconsin. The old blends with the new in this collection, with traditional flavors like our famous cold smoked gouda side by side with Fratello, our original Italian-style blend. Spice lovers will find plenty to love as well. The perfect birthday gift for the cheese enthusiast!
Contents:
Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.
Eight 6 oz. blocks of artisan Wisconsin cheese (Dill Havarti, 3 Amigos Gouda, Honey Sriracha Gouda, Smoked Mozzarella, Scorpion Pepper Gouda, Smoked Gouda, Fratello (an original, meltable Italian blend), and Mango Habanero Gouda
"Have a Cheesy Birthday" sticker on box
Pictured cupcake not included.
Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page.
Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge.
*Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged.
Ingredients
Dill Havarti: Cultured pasteurized milk, dill, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring.
Sharp Cheddar: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes.
Smoked Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring.
Fratello: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes.
Please contact us to inquire about local product ingredients in this collection.
-11% sale
The Brotherhood Cheese Assortment Pack (8 Cheeses)
$62.95
$69.95
Description
Shipping
Ingredients
This one's got it all... literally. Every single one of our Cheese Brothers signature cheeses is in this assortment, from crowd-pleasers like our Dill Havarti to those for more spicy palettes like El Diablo. Great for parties, gifts, and for building an instant cheese collection.
*If temperatures at your location are above 60 degrees, your package will arrive in an insulated box and not in the pictured gift box. Please review our shipping policy for additional details.
Contents:
Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.
Eight 6 oz. blocks of Wisconsin cheese (honey sriracha gouda, fratello, dill havarti, smoked gouda, el diablo scorpion pepper gouda, 3 amigos spicy gouda, mango habanero gouda, smoked mozzarella).
Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page.
Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge.
*Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this box as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions.
Ingredients
"El Diablo" Scorpion Pepper Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, scorpion chili peppers, annatto coloring.
"Bantam" Honey Sriracha Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. Flavoring: Honey granules, salt, spices, dextrose, onion, sriracha sauce (aged cayenne red peppers, vinegar, garlic), sugar, brown sugar, garlic powder, maltodextrin, sodium diacetate, natural flavor.
"El Perrito" Mango Habanero Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring. Flavoring: Sugar, dried honey (refinery syrup, honey), maltodextrin, habanero peppers, spices, natural mango flavor.
3 Amigos: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, jalapeno, habanero, chipotle peppers, annatto coloring.
Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring.
"Nonna Mozz" Smoked Mozzarella: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring.
"Old Smoky" Smoked Gouda: Cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, annatto coloring.
"Harvest" Dill Havarti: Cultured pasteurized milk and cream, salt, dill, enzymes, annatto coloring."
-20% sale
Just About Everything Box *New Release*
$236.76
$295.95
Description
Shipping
Ingredients
This monumental collection includes all of our best cheeses and treats from the Dairy State. Go on a cheese journey of discovery with 26 cheeses, from our squeaky fresh cheese curds to our 15-Year-Aged Wisconsin Cheddar. Pair them with an assortment of artisanal foods like Ames farm fresh honey and Wisconsin-made Cherry Lavender Jam. Display them all on a Cheese Brothers cutting board. A truly abundant gift for the die-hard cheese lover.
Contents:
Note: Contents may vary slightly from listed depending upon seasonal availability.
Sixteen 6 oz. blocks of Wisconsin-made cheese (Smoked Gouda, Dill Havarti, Fratello, Smoked Mozzarella, Honey Sriracha Gouda, 3 Amigos Spicy Gouda, Mango Habenero Gouda, Diablo Scorpion Pepper Gouda, Bourbon Gouda, Smoked Provolone, Smoked Cheddar, Havarti, Gouda, Horseradish Cheddar, Green Onion Cheddar, Adelheid Alpine-Style)
Six 5 oz. blocks of Wisconsin-made specialty reserve cheese (8-Year-Aged Cheddar, Northwoods Parmesan, Wisconsin Gruyere, 15-Year-Aged Cheddar, Door County Duet, Trappiste Ale-Washed Gouda).
One 8 oz. bags of squeaky fresh Wisconsin-made Bloody Mary cheese curds
Two 6 oz. bag of squeaky fresh Classic and Garlic Dill cheese curds
One 8 oz. block of Golden Baked Bliss (our top seller)
Two 8 oz. summer sausages from our very own Barron Sausage Co.
One 8 oz. jar of Cherry Lavender Jam from Bushel and Peck's of Beloit, WI
One 8 oz. jar of Bier Hall Stone Ground Mustard from Iron Ridge, WI
One 5 oz. pack of classic white organic crackers from Potter's Crackers of Madison, WI
One 5 oz. package of bite-sized caramels by Sugarwood of Cumberland, WI
One 2 oz. jar of single source raw honey from Ames Honey Farm
One 11'' bamboo Cheese Brothers cutting board
Do you have a large order of 10 or more gift packs? Learn more about our large quantity gift package options at our Business Gifts page.
Mindful Packing & ShippingWe take care to protect the integrity of your cheese in transit. Our vacuum-sealed, hard cheeses are safe outside of refrigeration in transit. If temperatures are above 60 degrees in your location, we ship in insulated boxes with gel ice packs to protect your shipment, at no extra charge.
*Please note that insulated shipping in the summer and to locations above 60 degrees will alter the appearance of this collection as pictured. Please email talk@cheesebros.com with any questions about how your order will be packaged.
Ingredients
Box contents will vary. Please refer to individual product packaging for ingredient information. Please contact us to inquire about product ingredients in this collection.
Copyright ©2026. The Pepper Pantry. All Rights Reserved.