All products
BBQ Sauces
Butterfly Bakery Of Vermont Hot Sauce
Da' Bomb
Dawson's Hot Sauce
Dirty Dick's
Gift Box Sets and Special Collections
Heartbeat Hot Sauce
Historic Lynchburg
Hot Sauces
Jams and Jellies
Marie Sharp's
Marie Sharp's Best By/Buy 50 % off Select Sauces | Limited Stock
Merchandise
Mike's Hot Honey
Rich's Backyard Seasoning
Rufus Teague
SALE
Seasonings & Rubs
The Pepper Pantry - SHOP ALL
Pantry Pack Mixed Set of Four
$47.25
$52.50
Try a pack of four of our newest product offerings!
FOUR pack includes:
Heartbeat Pineapple Habanero Hot Sauce
Heartbeat has yet again collaborated with an Ontario craft brewery, this time from their hometown of Thunder Bay. Made with the help of Sleeping Giant Brewery's award-winning Beaver Duck session IPA, this sauce has a boldly pronounced fruitiness and a bright but savory vibe from start to finish. This sauce has a very approachable balance of heat and flavor, a Heartbeat signature characteristic!
Historic Lynchburg Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning
Historic Lynchburg Tennessee Whiskey Nashville Hot Chicken Seasoning is a sure fire way to get perfect Nashville chicken flavor every time.
Mike's Hot Honey
Honey with a Kick | America's #1 Brand of Hot HoneyMike's Hot Honey is a sweet-heat combo of honey infused with chili peppers that adds the perfect kick to all of your favorite foods.
Da' Bomb Beyond Insanity Hot Sauce
The ultimate in hot. Da'Bomb Beyond Insanity is "The Hot Sauce that Everyone Loves to Hate". This sauce is way past insanity. As seen on the First We Feast series Hot Ones. Rated at 135,600 Scoville units.
Dawson's Four Pack Set
$45.90
$51.00
Introducing our newest addition, the Dawson's Four Pack!
Set includes:
Dawson's Original Hot Sauce | Hot Ones Season 5 Sauce #7 5 oz.
Fresh red Habanero peppers are the lead flavour in Dawson’s Original Hot. This sauce is spicy and rich with sweet tones and a smooth texture that coats your taste buds for a lovely finish. Try Original Hot on sandwiches, pizza, pasta, wings and tacos. For those who cook at home, we suggest searing meats, mixing small amounts into salad dressings, marinades and even of some homemade popcorn!
Heat 8/10
Ingredients: Habanero, Peppers, Vinegar, Sugars (cane sugar), Extra virgin Olive oil, Garlic, Sea salt.
Dawson's Sweet Pear Chili Hot Sauce 5 oz.
With a delightful blend of Bosc pear and ripe fiery hot Vietnamese chili peppers, Dawson's 'Sweet Pear Chili' is a unique, naturally sweet tasting hot sauce for all to enjoy. Try it on sandwiches, pizza, fish or mixing with sauces for a sweet kick.
Heat 6.5/10
Ingredients: Pear, Vinegar, Chili pepper, Garlic, Extra virgin olive oil, Lime, Sea salt, Black pepper.
Dawson's Zuzu's 7-Pot Hot Sauce | Hot Ones Season 22 Sauce #9 5 oz.
Zuzu's 7-Pot Sauce is our newest sauce, coming hot off season 22 of Hot Ones! In the #9 spot, this sauce packs a big heat, with a unique flavour profile. It's upfront heat comes from the infamous 7-Pot, with a blend of red bell pepper for balance. Licorice notes from Sambuca and fennel, rounded with a slight sweetness from maple syrup. Great with wings, pizza, pasta, and as a marinade.
Heat 9/10
Ingredients: Red pepper, 7-pot mash (7-pot peppers, vinegar), garlic, sugars (maple syrup), vinegar, extra virgin olive oil, sambuca, fennel seed, ghost pepper, sea salt
Dawson's Cedar Smoked Garlic Hot Sauce | Hot Ones Season 17 Sauce #2 5 oz.
Cedar Smoked Garlic is our most complex sauce to date. Smoked garlic, fermented habanero, and a specially crafted white wine vinegar brings this sauce together like nothing we've ever experienced. Rich, medium heat, and a delightful woodsy finish. This sauce is a one of a kind and we can't wait to share it with you.
Heat 5/10
Ingredients: White wine vinegar, Habanero Mash (Habanero, Vinegar), Garlic, Onion, Extra virgin olive oil, Sea salt, Sumac.
Heartbeat 4 Pack Set
$43.20
$48.00
Heartbeat Camp Sauce Hot Sauce 6 oz.
This sauce is a love letter to our summers spent camping. Growing up in Northwestern Ontario, it was Quetico, Neys, and Algonquin Park. We tried to bottle the feeling. Something that pairs equally with breakfast sandwiches, hot dogs and fresh caught fish.
Crafted with Scotch Bonnet peppers, dates, malt vinegar, smoked paprika, maple syrup and sea salt.
Ingredients: Distilled vinegar, Sugars (dates, maple syrup), Red bell pepper, Onion, Jalapeño, Scotch bonnet pepper, Light olive oil, Garlic, Chipotle in adobo (chipotle peppers, water, tomato puree, vinegar, salt, sugar, garlic, canola oil), Mait vinegar,Sea salt, Smoked paprika
CONTAINS: Barley
Heartbeat Dill Pickle Serrano Hot Sauce 6 oz.
Your new favorite condiment! Heartbeat Dill Pickle Serrano sauce recreates the perfect, sour, garlicky dill pickle with a little extra spice! With mild to medium, crowd pleasing heat, this is a great sauce for your family barbecue. Try it on some classics like Burgers, Hot Dogs, Caesars, Pasta Salad and your Tuna Salad Sandwich...and then let your imagination run wild!
INGREDIENTS:
Vinegar, Onion, Jalapeno, Cucumber, Serrano Pepper, Sea Salt, Garlic, Dill, Canola Oil, Spices, Mustard Seed*Vegan & Gluten Free
Heartbeat Caribbean Style Mango Habanero Hot Sauce 6 oz.
Heartbeat Hot Sauce Caribbean Style Mango Habanero
A special collaboration with Tomlin, the restaurant where Heartbeat Hot Sauce was born. This sauce was originally a limited edition only available in our hometown of Thunder Bay, but quickly became a cult favorite.Ingredients: Mango, Rice Wine Vinegar, Orange Bell Pepper, Onion, Lime Juice, Orange Habanero, Canola Oil, Organic Cane Sugar, Garlic, Sea Salt, Cilantro, Spices
Heartbeat Scorpion Hot Sauce 6 oz.
Heartbeat's hottest sauce yet, this new recipe features Trinidad Scorpion Peppers to get your blood pumping! Even with a unique combination of ingredients, including beets, red bell peppers and chipotles in adobo, this sauce still has the well-balanced versatility you've come to expect from the Heartbeat lineup. With its hot but not too-hot spice level and nuanced flavor, this sauce makes just about any food sing: eggs, pizza, tacos and more. Your new go-to!
INGREDIENTS: Vinegar, red peppers, habaneros, beets, onions, garlic, Trinidad Scorpion Peppers, Chipotles in adobo (red chipotle pepper, water, vinegar, sugar, salt, tomato paste, smoke essence, onion, garlic), salt, lemon juice, canola oil, spices
*Vegan & Gluten Free
Dirty Dick's 4 Pack Set
$36.00
$40.00
Get a four pack of one of our newest offerings by Dirty Dick's
Dirty DIck's Caribbean Dreams Hot Sauce 5 oz. (Two Bottles)
A Barbados style, mustard-based hot sauce from the exceptional Dirty Dick's. This is a good complement to basically any meat, especially meats cooked on the grill.
Heat Index: 5 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Habanero peppers, pears, peaches, pineapple juice, apple cider vinegar, mustard, apple juice, brown sugar, honey, and fresh spices.
Made in Vermont
Dirty Dick's Tropical Twist Hot Sauce 5 oz. (Two Bottles)
Dirty Dick’s Hot Sauce blends habanero peppers with tropical fruits for a sweet and spicy sauce. Let the sweetness of bananas, raisins, and pineapples linger on your palate and wait for the heat to kick in. Great for beef stir-fry, chicken wraps, and as a stand-alone dipping sauce for the daring.
Heat Index: 5 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Habanero Peppers, Mangoes, Pineapple, Vinegar, Bananas, Tomatoes, Brown Sugar, Sultanas, Onions, Garlic, Salt & Spices.
Made in Vermont.
Mike's Hot Honey Original Pack of 2
$24.30
$27.00
Combo Pack featuring TWO Mike's Hot Honey 12 oz Squeeze Bottles
Honey with a Kick | America's #1 Brand of Hot HoneyMike's Hot Honey is a sweet-heat combo of honey infused with chili peppers that adds the perfect kick to all of your favorite foods.
Ways To EnjoyDrizzle it on pizza, fried chicken or BBQ. Pair with your favorite cheese and add to cocktails or tea. Mix into dressings or marinades and even drizzle on ice cream!
IngredientsMade with 100% pure honey, real chili peppers and vinegar.Mike's Hot Honey is all natural, gluten-free, paleo-friendly and contains no artificial sugar or preservatives.
Dawson's Zuzu's 7-Pot Hot Sauce | Hot Ones Season 22 Sauce #9 5 oz.
$12.00
$15.00
Zuzu's 7-Pot Sauce is our newest sauce, coming hot off season 22 of Hot Ones! In the #9 spot, this sauce packs a big heat, with a unique flavour profile. It's upfront heat comes from the infamous 7-Pot, with a blend of red bell pepper for balance. Licorice notes from Sambuca and fennel, rounded with a slight sweetness from maple syrup. Great with wings, pizza, pasta, and as a marinade.
Heat 9/10
Ingredients: Red pepper, 7-pot mash (7-pot peppers, vinegar), garlic, sugars (maple syrup), vinegar, extra virgin olive oil, sambuca, fennel seed, ghost pepper, sea salt
Dawson's Cedar Smoked Garlic Hot Sauce | Ones Season 17 Sauce #2 5 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
Cedar Smoked Garlic is our most complex sauce to date. Smoked garlic, fermented habanero, and a specially crafted white wine vinegar brings this sauce together like nothing we've ever experienced. Rich, medium heat, and a delightful woodsy finish. This sauce is a one of a kind and we can't wait to share it with you.
Heat 5/10
Ingredients: White wine vinegar, Habanero Mash (Habanero, Vinegar), Garlic, Onion, Extra virgin olive oil, Sea salt, Sumac.
Dawson's Shawarma Sauce | Hot Ones Season 13 Sauce #2 5 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
This sauce is heavily influenced by Middle Eastern spice blends and the culture of take-out Shawarma shops. Our Shawarma Sauce is mild, incredibly bright in taste, with smooth notes from garlic, extra virgin olive oil and honey. The spice blend is familiar, yet unique in a hot sauce and a must try!
Heat 3/10
Ingredients: Hot peppers, Peppers, Vinegar, Garlic, Extra virgin olive oil, Honey, Spices, Red chili pepper, Sea salt, Granulated garlic, Chili powder.
Dawson's Original Hot Sauce | Hot Ones Season 5 Sauce #7 5 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
Fresh red Habanero peppers are the lead flavour in Dawson’s Original Hot. This sauce is spicy and rich with sweet tones and a smooth texture that coats your taste buds for a lovely finish. Try Original Hot on sandwiches, pizza, pasta, wings and tacos. For those who cook at home, we suggest searing meats, mixing small amounts into salad dressings, marinades and even of some homemade popcorn!
Heat 8/10
Ingredients: Habanero, Peppers, Vinegar, Sugars (cane sugar), Extra virgin Olive oil, Garlic, Sea salt.
Dawson's Hot Dog Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
This sauce has been designed to be the perfect hot sauce, for a spicier dog. Finally, mustard and ketchup have a new best friend! With a nice tan colour, thick body, and red speckle from the dates, this sauce is here to stay. Hot Dog Doug can't wait to tag along on your BBQ's, baseball games, and summer hangouts.
Heat 4.5/10
Ingredients: Onion, Vinegar, Garlic, Canola oil, Dates, Habanero mash (habanero, vinegar), Sugars (cane sugar), Sea Salt.
Dawson's Sweet Pear Chili Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
With a delightful blend of Bosc pear and ripe fiery hot Vietnamese chili peppers, Dawson's 'Sweet Pear Chili' is a unique, naturally sweet tasting hot sauce for all to enjoy. Try it on sandwiches, pizza, fish or mixing with sauces for a sweet kick.
Heat 6.5/10
Ingredients: Pear, Vinegar, Chili pepper, Garlic, Extra virgin olive oil, Lime, Sea salt, Black pepper.
Da' Bomb Beyond Insanity Hot Sauce
$14.00
$18.00
The ultimate in hot. Da'Bomb Beyond Insanity is "The Hot Sauce that Everyone Loves to Hate". This sauce is way past insanity. As seen on the First We Feast series Hot Ones. Rated at 135,600 Scoville units.
More InformationBrand/Collection Da'BombSize 4 ozHeat 5/5Scoville Units 135,600 Scoville Units Dietary Summary Gluten Free, Vegan
Mike's Hot Honey 12oz Bottle
$13.50
Mike's Hot Honey 12 oz Squeeze BottleHoney with a Kick | America's #1 Brand of Hot HoneyMike's Hot Honey is a sweet-heat combo of honey infused with chili peppers that adds the perfect kick to all of your favorite foods.
Ways To EnjoyDrizzle it on pizza, fried chicken or BBQ. Pair with your favorite cheese and add to cocktails or tea. Mix into dressings or marinades and even drizzle on ice cream!
IngredientsMade with 100% pure honey, real chili peppers and vinegar.Mike's Hot Honey is all natural, gluten-free, paleo-friendly and contains no artificial sugar or preservatives.
Packaging SpecsNet Wt. 12 oz (340g) PET plastic squeeze bottle with flip top cap.
Mike's Hot Honey: Extra Hot
$13.50
Honey with an Extra KickThe same sweet-heat combo you love from our original, only this time we've kicked it up a notch. A new experience for Mike's Hot Honey fans and heat lovers of all kinds.
Feel the heat!Staying true to Mike's signature slow-building heat, Mike's Hot Honey - Extra Hot can be used interchangeably with the original flavor to give an extra kick to any dish.
Ways To EnjoyExtra Hot can be used to give sweetness and heat to any dish or beverage, but its extra kick is particularly suited for pizza, chicken, BBQ, marinades and cocktails.
IngredientsMade with 100% pure honey, real chili peppers and vinegar.Mike's Hot Honey is all natural, gluten-free, paleo-friendly and contains no artificial sugar or preservatives.
Butterfly Bakery Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$10.00
$11.50
Get ready for garlicky maple sweet heat. This is one of our most popular hot sauces and is made with some spectacular red jalapenos, organic garlic scapes and pure Vermont maple syrup.
Also a 2-time Hot Pepper Award Winner!
All Butterfly Bakery Vermont hot sauces are made exclusively with Vermont peppers. Butterfly Bakery Vermont began mass producing hot sauces in 2015 and within two years was the largest purchaser of Vermont peppers.
Heat Index: 4 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Dog Rive Farm jalapenos, organic white vinegar, Eastview Farm garlic scapes, Eastman Long & Sons pure Vermont maple syrup, salt.
Made in Vermont.
Butterfly Bakery Vermont Cilantro Onion Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$10.00
$11.50
Straight forward and simple with mid-level heat, this is the signature "use on anything and everything" Butterfly Bakery Vermont hot sauce made with green jalapenos, robust cilantro and sweet Vermont onions.
All Butterfly Bakery Vermont hot sauces are made exclusively with Vermont peppers. Butterfly Bakery Vermont began mass producing hot sauces in 2015 and within two years was the largest purchaser of Vermont peppers.
Heat Index: 4 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Maple Wind Farm jalapenos, organic white vinegar, Fusda Farm onions, Kingsbury Market Garden cilantro, salt.
Made in Vermont.
Butterfly Bakery Vermont Maple Rum Chipotle Hot Sauce - 5 oz.
$10.00
$11.50
This hot sauce is a warm hug of St. Johnsbury Distillery's Maple Rum, Vermont jalapenos that we maple wood smoke ourselves, and a sweet splash of pure Vermont maple syrup. This makes for a great pizza and chili sauce.
All Butterfly Bakery Vermont hot sauces are made exclusively with Vermont peppers. Butterfly Bakery Vermont began mass producing hot sauces in 2015 and within two years was the largest purchaser of Vermont peppers.
Heat Index: 4 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients:Maplewood smoked Shadow Creek Farm jalapeno peppers, organic distilled vinegar, Eastman Long & Sons maple syrup, Dunc's Mill Maple Rum, Salt.
Made in Vermont.
Butterfly Bakery Vermont Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$12.00
$14.00
Taco Vibes Only is a vibrant, painfully joyous hot sauce that will bring those tasty taco vibes to the table. It's a stealthy sauce that starts out exceptionally hot, digs in, and just gets hotter. It's excruciating perfection on tacos, chicken wings and "friendemies."
AS SEEN ON HOT ONES!
Ingredients: Organic distilled white vinegar, red Serrano peppers, reaper peppers, lime juice, ghost peppers, garlic scapes, salt, reaper pepper powder, coriander, cumin.
Heat: EXTREMELY HOT. 638,000 Scovilles!
Dirty Dick's Caribbean Dreams Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$7.50
$10.00
A Barbados style, mustard-based hot sauce from the exceptional Dirty Dick's. This is a good complement to basically any meat, especially meats cooked on the grill.
Heat Index: 5 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Habanero peppers, pears, peaches, pineapple juice, apple cider vinegar, mustard, apple juice, brown sugar, honey, and fresh spices.
Made in Vermont
Dirty Dick's Peachy Green Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$7.50
$10.00
Introduced in 2017 by Dirty Dick's, this sauce took home first place in the Fruit Based Medium Hot category at the 2018 NYC Hot Sauce Expo. This is no surprise for those who are familiar with the Dirty Dick's line.
Heat Index: 5 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Serrano peppers, jalapeno peppers, peaches, bell peppers, vinegar, fresh scallions, honey, lemon, lime, pineapple, brown sugar, spices, vanilla, and saffron.
Made in Vermont
Dirty Dick's Tropical Twist Hot Sauce 5 oz.
$7.50
$10.00
Dirty Dick’s Hot Sauce blends habanero peppers with tropical fruits for a sweet and spicy sauce. Let the sweetness of bananas, raisins, and pineapples linger on your palate and wait for the heat to kick in. Great for beef stir-fry, chicken wraps, and as a stand-alone dipping sauce for the daring.
Dirty Dick offers three varieties, with this one being the original and most award winning. Here are some of this sauce's many awards:
2018 NYC Hot Sauce Expo Screaming Mimi GRAND WORLD CHAMPION
2018 Chile Pepper Magazine Fiery Food Challenge 1st Place Fruit Based Sauce
2017 NYC Hot Sauce Expo Screaming Mimi GRAND WORLD CHAMPION
2016 NYC Hot Sauce Expo Screaming Mimi First Place Fruit Based Hot
2015 Chile Pepper Magazine Golden Chile Awards First Place Fruit Based Hot/Extra Hot
2015 NYC Hot Sauce Expo Screaming Mimi Second Place Fruit Based Hot
2014 NYC Hot Sauce Expo Screaming Mimi Second Place Fruit Based Hot
2014 Scovie Awards First Place Hot Sauce World Beat
2013 NYC Hot Sauce Expo Screaming Mimi First Place Fruit Based Hot
2012 Official Hot Sauce Meatopia New York City
2011 Official Hot Sauce Meatopia New York City
2008 National Barbecue Association Second Place Hot Sauce
2006 National Barbecue Association First Place Hot Sauce
Heat Index: 5 of 10
Size: 5 fl. oz.
Ingredients: Habanero Peppers, Mangoes, Pineapple, Vinegar, Bananas, Tomatoes, Brown Sugar, Sultanas, Onions, Garlic, Salt & Spices.
Made in Vermont.
Heartbeat Camp Sauce 6 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
This sauce is a love letter to our summers spent camping. Growing up in Northwestern Ontario, it was Quetico, Neys, and Algonquin Park. We tried to bottle the feeling. Something that pairs equally with breakfast sandwiches, hot dogs and fresh caught fish.
Crafted with Scotch Bonnet peppers, dates, malt vinegar, smoked paprika, maple syrup and sea salt.
Ingredients: Distilled vinegar, Sugars (dates, maple syrup), Red bell pepper, Onion, Jalapeño, Scotch bonnet pepper, Light olive oil, Garlic, Chipotle in adobo (chipotle peppers, water, tomato puree, vinegar, salt, sugar, garlic, canola oil), Mait vinegar,Sea salt, Smoked paprika
CONTAINS: Barley
Heartbeat Caribbean Style Mango Habanero Hot Sauce 6 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
Heartbeat Hot Sauce Caribbean Style Mango Habanero
A special collaboration with Tomlin, the restaurant where Heartbeat Hot Sauce was born. This sauce was originally a limited edition only available in our hometown of Thunder Bay, but quickly became a cult favorite.Ingredients: Mango, Rice Wine Vinegar, Orange Bell Pepper, Onion, Lime Juice, Orange Habanero, Canola Oil, Organic Cane Sugar, Garlic, Sea Salt, Cilantro, Spices
Heartbeat Dill Pickle Serrano, 6 oz.
$10.00
$12.00
Your new favorite condiment! Heartbeat Dill Pickle Serrano sauce recreates the perfect, sour, garlicky dill pickle with a little extra spice! With mild to medium, crowd pleasing heat, this is a great sauce for your family barbecue. Try it on some classics like Burgers, Hot Dogs, Caesars, Pasta Salad and your Tuna Salad Sandwich...and then let your imagination run wild!
INGREDIENTS:
Vinegar, Onion, Jalapeno, Cucumber, Serrano Pepper, Sea Salt, Garlic, Dill, Canola Oil, Spices, Mustard Seed*Vegan & Gluten Free
Heat: 2/10